Friday, January 8, 2021

Everything But The Tooth Fairy

No doubt about it...this post will anger a lot of people. However, I think it’s important to address the two 800 pound gorillas in the room. 

Let me start by with a condemnation of any lies told by any timeshare salesperson. They are a menace to everyone, do enormous damage to the industry and should be thrown out of the industry, if not prosecuted. 

Now, to the gorillas in the room. 

Gorilla Number 1-The easiest way to eliminate this menace is for people to stop attending sales pitches and stop buying timeshare until they check out some of the outlandish claims below. 

Gorilla Number 2-The outlandish claims below are so easily refuted that it strains my brain to think that anyone would believe them without so much as a cursory Internet search. 

Despite what some people would like you to believe, not every person who fell for one or more lies is a 90 year old disabled person. These are relative healthy, in charge of their mental faculties and no doubt walk into a sales presentation with a smart phone capable of more calculations than a roomful of computers that helped send men to the moon in 1969. 

There is absolutely no reason for anyone to fall for any of these lies. No reason at all, unless they also believe in The Tooth Fairy. 

I’ve redacted the developers’ name in the list below because sadly, many developers are guilty of these lies. 

Limo service from airport to the resort

Because we are not silver we can't see all of the resort options 

We could use points to pay maintenance fees

That at silver status you get to choose your room

That the conversion ratio for cruises was much higher then it really was

That we could rent out nights out through a rental agency that worked with the developer for a large profit

That inventory in Hawaii was almost sold out(that was over 10 years ago)

That the value of the ownership would increase

Failed to disclose the special assessment for the water intrusion that they were aware of before we bought but we had to pay

That this investment will groe

When you sell you will get most of your money back.maybe a profit

That you could use points to book these amazing hotels in NYC, and all over the world using points but failed to disclose the huge number of points needed

Book a week and then the developer will pay you to use the week for free deals for prospective owners 

Pay the maintenance fees with points-didn’t tell us how many it took to qualify

That you can use points to pay for your maintenance fee

We were told the timeshare room off the pool would be “Splashes Restaurant “ for owners to enjoy.  25 years later and it’s still restricted to timeshare presentations

That we can bring our dogs to any of the locations

If we became platinum, then after 3 years the developer would buy out the 90K equity that we had paid into membership

If you don’t want the points in a few years time no problem just sell them back to us

Being told I only needed 5000 points as I could book all my holidays at half points

They told us that our maintenance fees would go up to $70,000 in ten years if we didn’t move our points over to the elite program. We pay less than 3,000

That I had lost my equity in the time share but could get it back if I upgraded

I was told it would cost me $82,000 to convert to the new contract.  If I didn't I was told my maintenance fees would be $30,000 a year in 5 years

I could easily refinance for 1.2%

That we could sell our points and get out in the future

That we could reimburse unused points for checks for 'travel outside of diamond' and use it to pay our maintenance fees 

We were told that points were just like real estate

When we refused to give our SS number to the salesperson and we finally gave it since she promised they would not run a credit check. Our credit reporting company later informed us that they did run a credit check on each of us. 

We’d have no cost valet parking at the resort

Sample/trial points would never expire

I was told I could sell back.    When we decided we didn’t need the timeshare anymore we were told the only way to get out was to convert to points first then we could sell back

I was told if we upgraded to silver that the maintenance fees would go away

That we could use our points right away —at least two days after signing. We tried a month after but no points available

Incredible isn’t it?  

If you’re angry, I’ve done my job. Well, the first part of my job. In the next month or so, I’ll be unveiling a new partnership that will go a long way to preventing these lies from being told and believed. There’s a caveat to this of course; consumers need to understand that they, not the salespeople or the developers have the ultimate power to bring about change. 

Now if you’ll excuse me, I have to see if The Tooth Fairy has been spotted around here. 



Tuesday, January 5, 2021

New Year...Same Old Stories

As 2021 dawns, I’m pleased to announce that there’s been a seismic change in timeshare. 

Yeah, right. It’s the same old lies being told and the same old lies being believed, resulting in anger, frustration and a continuing bad reputation for the industry. 

Consider this recent encounter:

“We were told that if we bought 6000 more points and moved up to platinum, we would never have to pay any maintenance fees or assessments as long as we booked 20,000 points a year.  And our children would never have to pay either, as long as 20,000 points were used for bookings each year.  And none of us would ever need to go to the sales pitch again, and a booking for single bedroom would be automatically upgraded to two bedrooms at the one bedroom rate.  First time we tried to use that we were told we could only get the upgrade if we go to the talk.” 

None of this was in writing of course.  The consumer didn’t bother to ask about these ‘benefits’ during the closing.  Nor did they read the contract or do some basic research during the rescission period. 

Buckle up people. It seems we’re in for yet another year of status quo. Unless...wait, is that a glimmer of hope out there?  It is. Stay tuned. 

Thursday, December 17, 2020

Timeshare Basics

Since consumers continue to attend timeshare presentations having done no research and timeshare owners sometimes forget the basics, I thought it would be good to go over some basic information. 

What is timeshare?

In the most basic terms, timeshare is buying and owning your vacation accommodations, as opposed to renting a hotel room, resort room or vacation home.  The difference between timeshare and whole ownership of a vacation or second home is that you only purchase and own the amount of time that you plan on using each year.  


How do I buy a timeshare?

Timeshares can be purchased on the primary market, i.e. from the developer, or on the secondary market from an existing owner.  Developer sales are generally onsite at the resort, while secondary market sales can occur online between consumers, via a licensed broker, or in some cases through the developer.


Can I sell my timeshare?

In most cases, the legal answer is “yes.”  Although the value of the timeshare maybe far less than what you originally paid (see below) and some timeshares sell easier and faster than others. Timeshares can be sold if you no longer want/use it.


Why is the resale value of my timeshare so much less than what I paid for it?

Timeshares purchased on the primary market, e.g. from the developer, include the cost of building plus the cost to sell plus the profit margin, just as with any other product. Combine that with the fact that there are millions of timeshare units for sale on the secondary market and the fact that many developers are restricting the rights and benefits to secondary market purchasers, the value of most timeshare is considerably lower than most owners realize. It is simply supply vs. demand vs. benefit.


Is timeshare a real estate investment?

The short answer is NO.  Even if a timeshare is backed by physical real estates (and many timeshares are not), a timeshare should not be thought of as a real estate investment as a house, condo or other types of general real estate may be. A timeshare can be thought of as an investment in your future vacations.  You pay upfront now so that you can have vacations later.


What is the difference between timeshare weeks and timeshare points?

Timeshare weeks are the standard and are the simplest to understand and use.  Owners have the right to use 8 days 7 nights, consecutively per year, at a home resort or at another affiliated resort.  Point systems vary from developer to developer and from exchange company to exchange company, but all operate under the same premise; owners use their points as the currency to make accommodations and other reservations.


Can I donate my timeshare to a charity?

No charity will accept a timeshare due to the ongoing annual fees involved.  If you receive a call from anyone saying otherwise, promptly hang up. 


What happens if I stop paying my annual maintenance fees?

As mentioned above, timeshare ownership carries with it benefits and responsibilities.  One of those responsibilities is to pay your share of the annual maintenance fees levied by the resort.  Failure to pay these fees may result in losing your ownership rights and in many cases lead to a foreclosure, which can have a significant negative affect on your credit and your ability to purchase a major item or even obtain employment in the future.


What is an HOA and what does it do?

Your HOA or Home Owners’ Association is in charge of the management of the resort or in some cases, responsible for the hiring of the management company of the resort.  HOA duties include assessment of annual fees, budget, and/or special assessments, the day-to-day operations, determination of expenditures or improvements and staffing of the resort with the exception of the marketing and sales departments.  Individual owners are encouraged to get involved in their HOAs.


Is a timeshare the same as a vacation or travel club?

No.  While vacation and travel clubs differ, they are both are distinct from timeshare in that a vacation or travel club involve a membership vs. ownership rights.  If you are considering a purchase of a timeshare, vacation club or travel club and are unsure of the differencesdo your research before committing to anything.


I just received a call saying that someone wants to buy my timeshare…what should I do?

Hang up. It’s undoubtedly a scam. 

Thursday, December 10, 2020

Is Your Timeshare Worth More Than A Box Of Hotel Receipts?

Many, many, many years ago when I was a struggling timeshare salesperson, blissfully ignorant of anything but what my sales trainers had drilled into my head, I was often met with this question from my clients: “Can I sell the timeshare if I don’t want it anymore and for how much?”

The answer was always the same: “Yes, you can sell it. Let me ask you this, how much can you sell 25 years of hotel receipts for when you’re done vacationing?”

The first part of the answer was, and remains true. The right to sell your timeshare interests is part of the full bundle of rights. As to the so-called resale value of the timeshare, I never presented the timeshare as an investment and since resale value is based on many things, including supply and demand at any given time, I could not and did not provide a number, but rather reframed the consumer’s question. 

20 years later, it strikes me that both the industry and the owners have forgotten about my reframing question about hotel receipts. I think it’s high time we get back to looking at the truth. 

No matter what you pay for a hotel room over the years and no matter if there’s any inflation in that rate, the fact of the matter is that if you vacation and stay in hotel rooms, the cost of those accommodations is money spent not to be recouped. None of it. 

If you instead choose to purchase a timeshare, depending on many factors including what type/brand involved, you have a choice to sell it when you’re “done” with it and possibly recoup a minimal amount. What is a minimal amount?  Let’s use $1,500 as an example. 

If you purchase the right timeshare for your needs, you’ll probably have nicer/better/roomier/more luxurious accommodations than a typical hotel room you’d normally stay at. The resorts will probably have more amenities and if you’re smart enough to avoid the oh so incorrectly named “concierge” people pestering you for a sales pitch, oh sorry a resort overview, every time you check in, your stay will be better than a hotel in the area. 

Don’t get me will pay for this. You’ll probably pay more than you would for a hotel. That’s your choice. If you believe the money saving pitch your salesperson plied you with without doing any research, that’s your fault. Generally speaking, you pay more for nicer things. 

But here’s the thing; I don’t know where or when the price you could sell your timeshare after 20 years became such a big deal. So what if you paid $20,000 for it and could only sell it for $1,500. I assure you that box of hotel receipts can not be sold for $1,500. 

There are much bigger issues to deal with...the restrictions that developers place on secondary market purchases comes to mind.  More on that in a future post. 

Wednesday, November 11, 2020

Why So Many Rules And Restrictions For A Vacation?

These are the actual terms and conditions of a vacation package requiring a timeshare sales pitch. I’ve redacted the name of the resort as I’m fairly certain most of them have similar language. 

If the terms and conditions of a simple mini-vac require such arduous language, it’s no wonder the average purchaser can’t understand the language in a sales contract. 

Get some popcorn...this is a doozy. 


The vacation package being offered is provided by REDACTED (“Sponsor”), a Delaware limited liability company whose address is REDACTED. Sponsor is the developer and seller of REDACTED, a multi-site timeshare plan. 

You must attend a 90-minute minimum timeshare sales presentation about the benefits of being a member of REDACTED. If applicable, you must attend this presentation with your spouse or domestic partner. More time may be necessary if you choose to purchase. 

This offer is designed for individuals who are at least 30 years of age or older. Purchaser, and their spouse or domestic partner, if combining income, (hereinafter “Purchaser”) each party must present a valid state-issued driver's license (with the same mailing address) and a valid credit card (not attached to a debit account) at check-in for incidentals/security deposit.

Purchaser must have a gross annual household income of at least $70,000 and have a minimum credit score as established by this Sponsor. Purchaser may not have filed for bankruptcy or been adjudicated bankrupt or insolvent within the past 7 years. Only married couples and domestic partners attending a sales presentation at a REDACTED resort location (and who provide proof of cohabitation through government-issued identifications showing an identical home address) may combine their income, and, if married or in a domestic partnership, both spouses and domestic partners must attend the tour together. 

Employees of Sponsor and persons having attended a sales presentation with Sponsor within the last 12 months are ineligible to participate purchase a vacation package. 

Only one vacation package per household.

If applicable, REDACTED Owner Participation Requirement:

To be eligible for selected reservations and package use, ALL OWNERS on the Account are required to travel and attend the minimum 60-minute Owner Update together. The scheduled times of Owners Update depend on the property location of update. Failure of all parties on the Account to travel and attend the required presentation will result in forfeiture of the package and associated gift(s).

REDACTED  property owners' accounts cannot be in Collections, Bankruptcy nor have an active Loan Modification. REDACTED Owners/Members may not travel on a promotional package within 6 months of their most recent stay/tour.

This vacation package is designed for families and for recreational and vacation purposes, not to exceed a maximum of four (4) people per offer (four (4) person max (based on accommodations type). There is no obligation to purchase a timeshare interest. 

If you fail to attend the sales presentation or meet the requirements set forth in these Terms and Conditions, you understand that you will be charged the full retail value for the accommodations and any gift(s) received less the purchase price of the vacation package and will not receive any promotional gifts described herein. Promotional gifts, if included in the selected package, will be provided upon completion of the timeshare sales presentation and tour during the vacation, or sooner if required by law.

Purchaser must not be scheduled to attend any other timeshare sales presentation(s) at the destination region while staying or touring on any vacation package sponsored by REDACTED. 

Owners having attended a sales presentation with Sponsor within the last 6-months are ineligible to participate purchase a vacation package. Only one vacation package per household.

Group travel on this vacation package is not permitted. Group travel is defined as traveling with friends or family on separately purchased packages, to the same destination during overlapping travel dates.

Purchaser cannot attend the timeshare sales presentation on the date of arrival or date of departure. If attendance at a sales presentation is made under an exception on the date of departure, the guest must first check out of their accommodations and their flight must not depart within or less than 7 hours after scheduled tour time. Purchasers living within a 50-mile radius of the resort in the vacation package do not qualify to participate in this offer, but may qualify to participate in an offer at an alternative resort destination. This vacation package may NOT be used in combination with any other promotional offer or used in conjunction with any other vacation ownership interest. Two or more vacation packages may NOT be used at the same time to extend your travel dates.

This offer is non-refundable and non- transferable except as described herein or as required by law. Failure to comply with the rescheduling policy, attend the sales presentation, or meet the eligibility requirements will result in forfeiture of the package price and benefits of the package. You may cancel and request a refund at any time within thirty (30) days following the date that you purchased your vacation package, and the refund amount will be the purchase price of the vacation package less the retail value of any gift(s) and/or accommodations received. If you have used any of the days or nights accompanying this vacation package, you are ineligible to receive a refund. REDACTED reserves the right to cancel any reservations and issue a full refund for any reason until 3 days prior to scheduled check-in, whereas fees are 100% nonrefundable.

If a travel date was not selected when the vacation package is purchased, Purchaser must travel within 12 months from the date of purchase. Because the Sponsor subsidizes the cost of this vacation package in order to offer it to you at a discounted price, the Sponsor has instituted this Late Cancellation/No-Show Policy. Full pre-payment using a major credit card or debit card with the VISA or MC logo is required. Subject to any applicable statutory cancellation rights, this is a non-refundable, non-transferable advance purchase package. Purchaser may reschedule a reservation one time at no charge. A $65.00 charge applies to each reservation change thereafter. Any change made within 72 hours prior to check in or vacation no shows will be charged $90.00 if your accommodations were in a hotel or studio unit; $120.00 for a one-bedroom unit; and $150.00 for a two-bedroom unit. By purchasing a vacation package, you are agreeing to this policy.

Pets are not permitted in REDACTED properties. However, service animals as defined by the ADA are permitted. Emotional support animals are not recognized by the ADA as service animals. Thus, they are not permitted.

Sponsor and its direct and indirect parents, subsidiaries and affiliates, and each of their respective employees, officers, directors, shareholders, affiliates, and agents are not responsible for any printing or typographical errors contained herein. Sponsor is not responsible for any Acts of God, personal travel interruption, transportation costs, taxes, fees or personal illnesses preventing purchaser from using the vacation package within the provided time period. Medical, personal, physical or economic issues are the sole responsibility of the purchaser and do not provide a reason(s) for cancellation of package purchase outside of the provided period.

This promotion is intended to solicit purchasers of timeshare interests in REDACTED . The price range of the intervals is $8,200 to $40,075, plus annual dues. Prices subject to change. 

Void where prohibited by law. The verifiable retail value of this offer is from $595.00 to $1,500.00.

Notwithstanding any current or prior election to opt-in or opt-out of receiving telemarketing calls or SMS messages (including text messages), by entering my contact information, including my telephone number, I am giving REDACTED, its direct and indirect parents, subsidiaries, and affiliates (“REDACTED”) permission to contact me about this and future offers, at the telephone number, or physical or electronic address I have provided including SMS messages (including text messages), telephone calls using prerecorded messages or artificial voice, and calls and messages delivered using auto telephone dialing system or an automatic texting system. 

I understand that this permission overrides my listing on any state or federal Do Not Call list and any prior listing on the company Do Not Call list of REDACTED. I can opt-out of future calls at any time by requesting to be placed on the company Do Not Call list of REDACTED by calling REDACTED.


RIGHT TO CANCEL OR MODIFY PROMOTIONS AND TERMS AND CONDITIONS. Sponsor, in its sole discretion, reserves the right to cancel, terminate, modify, or suspend the Promotion in any way as deemed necessary by operational procedures and/or as otherwise mandated by State or Federal Laws.

Sponsor shall have no liability for any failure to comply with any provision of these Terms and Conditions due to occurrences beyond the Sponsor's control, including events that delay, hinder, or otherwise prevent the performance of any act required by Sponsor or in any way necessary to support the Promotion, including, without limitation, war (whether or not declared), revolution, riot, insurrection, strike, labor troubles, inability to procure materials or services necessary for performance, restrictive governmental laws or regulations, invasion, armed conflict, hostile act of foreign enemy, acts of terrorism (foreign or domestic), sabotage, radiation or chemical contamination, ionizing radiation, acts of nature (including without limitation, hurricane, tornado, flood, storm, tempest, wildfires, or earthquake), explosions, plague or other serious epidemics, public health emergencies, communicable disease outbreaks, or pandemics. If the product purchased becomes no longer valid due to associated changes then use of the package offer will be restricted, voided, forfeited, loss, or replaced with option of accommodations provision only. 

This constitutes the entire offer for the Promotion and no other representations, oral or otherwise, will apply.


This offer is not directed to residents in any state in which a registration of the timeshare plan is required but in which registration requirements have not yet been met.

Insane, isn’t it?  Why is this necessary?  

Monday, November 2, 2020

The Timeshare Industry Is Incapable Of Appreciating Their Own Product

 Yesterday was International Timeshare Appreciation Day, something I created 8 years ago as a way for timeshare owners around the world to celebrate everything that is good about timeshare. 

The industry has had 8 years to get behind this endeavor. No cost. No only one way of participating. 8 years. 

You have to wonder why they haven’t promoted the heck out of the observance , particularly this year when so many are finding it harder to celebrate timesharing. 

8 years. The only logical takeaway is that no one in the industry feels that there’s anything to appreciate about their own product. Disgraceful

Friday, October 23, 2020

Is There Such A Thing As A Good Timeshare?

 A reader writes in:

Hi Lisa,

Came across your blog and wondering if you might be able to provide some input?

My in-laws have a timeshare at the Maui Banyan in Kihei Hawaii that they purchased in 2004, paid off in 2014, they bought it for $20K, but with interest over the term, looks like $40k overall.

The maintenance fees about $900 or so, taxes about $200 per month, so figure on $1200/year, = $100/month. For 2 weeks, bankable (i think) and usable at other destinations.

What's the pros and cons of this type of timeshare? Why buy? Why not?

My response:

It’s a complicated question that I can’t answer comprehensively without knowing much more. 

I’ll say this much, the vast majority of timeshares that the developer is attempting to sell, including what your in-laws purchased, is available on the legitimate secondary market, albeit with some usage restrictions, for a small fraction of what the developer is selling it for. Add to that insult the fact that with rare exceptions, the resorts make inventory open to renters who can then get the benefits without the large buy in price and in some cases less than the annual fees. 

So from a purely financial standpoint, buying from the developer doesn’t seem all that wise. 

In my opinion, the industry has a long way to go before the value proposition of owning is back to what it used to be 20 or 25 years ago. 

And while I used to be a big proponent of timeshare points due to their flexibility, I no longer am. For the most part, they are unwieldy, I’m not 100% certain resorts are not overselling inventory and then there’s the fact that while a week in 2020 was a week in 1990 and will be a week in 2040; most point based timeshares offer no inflation protection leading to constant attempts to up sell the owner. 

Sure, the resorts are almost always nicer than a hotel. But as I pointed out, you don’t have to be an owner to stay at the resorts. 

So, while I’m still pro the concept of timeshare, I feel that in order to stay viable, the industry is going to have to do some serious retooling.